The Recapitulator would like to take this opportunity to ask a simple little math problem:
What happens to a ratio when the denominator decreases
and the numerator increases?
The P/E ratio (the inverse of its forward-earnings manifestation being the basis for comparison to the 10-year bond yield, which is also known as the "Fed Model"), which has never been a very good metric for valuation of companies in the REcapitulators opinion, owing to the usual retrospective/prospective predictive problems, has a special reverence for the public and sophisticated operators alike.
As for the Fed model, it has had a pretty good fun for predictive value. The Recapitulator has long thought July expiry is a good month for short VIX puts (or hey, why not "Texas Hedge" and go long some calls or long some futures???) and he still thinks so. As bond yields rise, forcing players to choose between similar yielding assets with vastly different risk profiles, and as the inverse of the forward earnings yield looks decidedly less rosy, we should see some excellent toing and froing next month.
Macro-economics, Investments, Law, and Power, with special emphasis on high finance and low humor.
Monday, June 18, 2007
Friday, June 15, 2007
Update
Updates will be more frequent now as yours truly has time to clear some idea backlogs...and now the post:
With all this talk about weather (and 4^15 cicadas here in Chicago), I
can't stop thinking about scale. We all know the importance of time intervals and sample periods when looking at the markets, and it is somewhat unfortunate we lack millions of years of data to strengthen our inferences or provide additional hypothesis generation.
the financial markets rife with feedback mechanisms, both on granular (individual stocks) and global (indexes) scales. Everything is connected and the thinking, human participants create another layer of complexity by adding 3rd (what do I think he thinks I am thinking??) order thinking into the mix.
Fortunately, the planet earth has a wonderful temperature regulation feedback system that serves to illuminate why global warming is a problem of scale – humans will have to actively engineer, on a massive scale (like blowing up the Rocky Mountains) carbon introduction into
the atmosphere in the future if we wish to live here.
The system can be characterized thusly: Plate tectonics produce carbon dioxide through volcanic emission, carbon dioxide warms the planet. Warming increasing weathering (surface water is a function of temperature, as temperature rises, water evaporates leading to clouds and subsequent erosion). Carbon dioxide then attaches chemically to silicate rocks experiencing weathering. This process removes the C02 from the atmosphere and cools the planet. Carbon Dioxide is introduced again by volcanic emission (and water is needed here as
well for subduction), and on and on.
This process that has kept the Planet at a relatively constant temperature (never below freezing and never above boiling) for around 4.5 Billion years. Planets need land, water, and plate tectonics to achieve this system that is very good for carrying life. An oceanic planet would not be a very nice place to live, and likely would not remain that way for long as the lack of temperature regulation would likely boil the planet. (in the spirit of good taste, I will withhold jokes regarding a certain movie starring Kevin Costner, as said movie has already experiences too much suffering)
This feedback loop is interesting to me because of its massive time scale. In the long run (geologic scale), we should be more worried about making more CO2. But on relatively short scales (hundreds of years), we may have a problem with increased temperatures due to our
own actions.
Looking at the markets, it is very clear what the "geologic" drift is, caused by an extremely complex feedback system of its own…but when you zoom in closer, it becomes apparent that too much on one side of the differential equation can kill 90% of "oxygen-dependent species".
Life does go on, but it takes a different scale of time for that to happen.
With all this talk about weather (and 4^15 cicadas here in Chicago), I
can't stop thinking about scale. We all know the importance of time intervals and sample periods when looking at the markets, and it is somewhat unfortunate we lack millions of years of data to strengthen our inferences or provide additional hypothesis generation.
the financial markets rife with feedback mechanisms, both on granular (individual stocks) and global (indexes) scales. Everything is connected and the thinking, human participants create another layer of complexity by adding 3rd (what do I think he thinks I am thinking??) order thinking into the mix.
Fortunately, the planet earth has a wonderful temperature regulation feedback system that serves to illuminate why global warming is a problem of scale – humans will have to actively engineer, on a massive scale (like blowing up the Rocky Mountains) carbon introduction into
the atmosphere in the future if we wish to live here.
The system can be characterized thusly: Plate tectonics produce carbon dioxide through volcanic emission, carbon dioxide warms the planet. Warming increasing weathering (surface water is a function of temperature, as temperature rises, water evaporates leading to clouds and subsequent erosion). Carbon dioxide then attaches chemically to silicate rocks experiencing weathering. This process removes the C02 from the atmosphere and cools the planet. Carbon Dioxide is introduced again by volcanic emission (and water is needed here as
well for subduction), and on and on.
This process that has kept the Planet at a relatively constant temperature (never below freezing and never above boiling) for around 4.5 Billion years. Planets need land, water, and plate tectonics to achieve this system that is very good for carrying life. An oceanic planet would not be a very nice place to live, and likely would not remain that way for long as the lack of temperature regulation would likely boil the planet. (in the spirit of good taste, I will withhold jokes regarding a certain movie starring Kevin Costner, as said movie has already experiences too much suffering)
This feedback loop is interesting to me because of its massive time scale. In the long run (geologic scale), we should be more worried about making more CO2. But on relatively short scales (hundreds of years), we may have a problem with increased temperatures due to our
own actions.
Looking at the markets, it is very clear what the "geologic" drift is, caused by an extremely complex feedback system of its own…but when you zoom in closer, it becomes apparent that too much on one side of the differential equation can kill 90% of "oxygen-dependent species".
Life does go on, but it takes a different scale of time for that to happen.
Monday, April 09, 2007
Federal Hurricane coverage and Cross Subsidization
The following article provides a nice, albeit journalistic, overview of pros and cons for a national catastrophe "backstop" fund.
http://www.palmbeachpost.com/politics/content/nation/epaper/2007/04/08/a13a_fedinsure_0408.html
The REcapitulator would only wish to remind his readers that such a fund, in economic terms, amounts to a massive cross subsidization from states that have little or no natural disaster exposure to states like Florida. This is precisely the sort of "noise" that has no clear "diode" (keeping with the circuitry analogy) for markets to efficiently allocate available capital. The following excerpt from the article is on point:
"While natural disasters may occur in any state, Nutter noted, most are economically modest. He also said 97 percent of all earthquake losses were in California and 75 percent of hurricane losses since 1900 were in Florida, Texas and Louisiana."
Another issue is, of course, pricing. The Federal coverage would ostensibly cover for mega-catastrophic risk. The REcapitulator is skeptical of any governments ability to price this
coverage in a way that optimally transmits information about the risks of mega-catastrophes.
http://www.palmbeachpost.com/politics/content/nation/epaper/2007/04/08/a13a_fedinsure_0408.html
The REcapitulator would only wish to remind his readers that such a fund, in economic terms, amounts to a massive cross subsidization from states that have little or no natural disaster exposure to states like Florida. This is precisely the sort of "noise" that has no clear "diode" (keeping with the circuitry analogy) for markets to efficiently allocate available capital. The following excerpt from the article is on point:
"While natural disasters may occur in any state, Nutter noted, most are economically modest. He also said 97 percent of all earthquake losses were in California and 75 percent of hurricane losses since 1900 were in Florida, Texas and Louisiana."
Another issue is, of course, pricing. The Federal coverage would ostensibly cover for mega-catastrophic risk. The REcapitulator is skeptical of any governments ability to price this
coverage in a way that optimally transmits information about the risks of mega-catastrophes.
Monday, March 26, 2007
Asset prices and the Fed
The conundrum the Fed faces with financial and real asset prices continues. In order to effectuate the "goldilocks" economy, the Fed must manage inflation expectations whilst turning another eye to asset prices. This behavior has some interesting side effects, the most prominent of which is what the REcapitualtor believes is an unhealthy regard for defacto central planning.
From Mishkin's latest speech, in which he all but states the management of the "correct" inflation expectations is the aim of the Fed:
"Although solidly anchored inflation expectations are indeed highly
desirable, they could pose a bit of a problem for monetary policy if
they were at a level somewhat above or below the rate preferred by
policymakers. Under such circumstances, the central bank would likely be
interested in shifting the public’s expectations in a more favorable
direction. Whether such adjustment would be easy or difficult is,
unfortunately, quite uncertain because we do not understand the
expectations-formation process very well"
Expectations are a "problem" if they are above or below the rate "preferred" by the Fed.
Mechanical inflation targeting (something that I abhor) is looking better all the time...
From Mishkin's latest speech, in which he all but states the management of the "correct" inflation expectations is the aim of the Fed:
"Although solidly anchored inflation expectations are indeed highly
desirable, they could pose a bit of a problem for monetary policy if
they were at a level somewhat above or below the rate preferred by
policymakers. Under such circumstances, the central bank would likely be
interested in shifting the public’s expectations in a more favorable
direction. Whether such adjustment would be easy or difficult is,
unfortunately, quite uncertain because we do not understand the
expectations-formation process very well"
Expectations are a "problem" if they are above or below the rate "preferred" by the Fed.
Mechanical inflation targeting (something that I abhor) is looking better all the time...
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
Leptokurtic
This lovely term is more affectionately known by statisticians as "fat tails", and describes probability distributions that assign more liklihood to extreme rare events.
There is a veritable ocean of literature regarding this subject, and the REcapitulator, as always, directs the diligent reader to the excellent SSRN site for further reading:
http://www.ssrn.com/
However, the REcapitulator would like to make a somewhat narrow comment. A normal distribution, or even most of the distributions that exhibit "fat tails" make the assumption that VARIANCE, the spread of possible values in relation to the expected value of a given variable, is STABLE. This is not true, as volatility in markets (as measured by the VIX) is also volatile.
If we have a normal distribution, we should also expect to see an additive generator of random variables.
But this is not what we actually see. In periods of high volatility, the generator is multiplicative.
In other words, whenever you see any statistic in markets that has a normal distribution as its intellectual lynchpin, be very skeptical of any conclusions derived therefrom.
There is a veritable ocean of literature regarding this subject, and the REcapitulator, as always, directs the diligent reader to the excellent SSRN site for further reading:
http://www.ssrn.com/
However, the REcapitulator would like to make a somewhat narrow comment. A normal distribution, or even most of the distributions that exhibit "fat tails" make the assumption that VARIANCE, the spread of possible values in relation to the expected value of a given variable, is STABLE. This is not true, as volatility in markets (as measured by the VIX) is also volatile.
If we have a normal distribution, we should also expect to see an additive generator of random variables.
But this is not what we actually see. In periods of high volatility, the generator is multiplicative.
In other words, whenever you see any statistic in markets that has a normal distribution as its intellectual lynchpin, be very skeptical of any conclusions derived therefrom.
Monday, March 19, 2007
A good example...
...of the capital markets at work, distributing risk in the appropriate manner and forcing innovation as to how risk is allocated. As stated in the last post regarding Buffet, the risks to Hurricane-prone areas have "increased", or at least the perception of that risk has increased with Katrina. Rating agencies who cover REinsurance companies are going to assess risk based on recent experience (the "availability" heuristic as popularized by Kahneman and Taversky's brilliant work on how humans actually make decisions). Rates increase.
Solutions will present themself...if government will allow them to. Finite risk, contingent capital solutions, etc. Perhaps a private homeowners captive will sprout out of the Keys.
Of course, global warming (or the perception of same) only serves to increase the risk, something risk providers (REinsurance companies) will be happy to provide for a price.
http://www.theledger.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070319/NEWS/703190347/1004
Solutions will present themself...if government will allow them to. Finite risk, contingent capital solutions, etc. Perhaps a private homeowners captive will sprout out of the Keys.
Of course, global warming (or the perception of same) only serves to increase the risk, something risk providers (REinsurance companies) will be happy to provide for a price.
http://www.theledger.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070319/NEWS/703190347/1004
Buffet's gambit
Berkshire profits up 56% year on year. Impressive.
However, the REcapitulator, would like to simplify the way Mr. Buffet makes his money.
1. Sell thousands of out of the money binary put options. In the insurance lexicon this means sell property and hurricane exposure policies with defined policy limits.
2. Price said options using a one-year history of data, with that year containing the worst hurricane in 100 years. As an aside, The REcapitulator is aware of the non-gaussian and epistemological difficulties with the weather, but he is merely describing
methodology here. Take advantage of the historical tradition of offering exposure to ONE year of negative events. In other words, double the price based on a rare event.
3. Invest the premium from all those options/polices into the global financial markets. Then hope (pray?) that another 100-year rare negative event does not occur.
In other words, short the rare 100-year event, go long the global finance markets, which have a 70% liklihood of increasing year on year. This is good risk taking.
However, the REcapitulator, would like to simplify the way Mr. Buffet makes his money.
1. Sell thousands of out of the money binary put options. In the insurance lexicon this means sell property and hurricane exposure policies with defined policy limits.
2. Price said options using a one-year history of data, with that year containing the worst hurricane in 100 years. As an aside, The REcapitulator is aware of the non-gaussian and epistemological difficulties with the weather, but he is merely describing
methodology here. Take advantage of the historical tradition of offering exposure to ONE year of negative events. In other words, double the price based on a rare event.
3. Invest the premium from all those options/polices into the global financial markets. Then hope (pray?) that another 100-year rare negative event does not occur.
In other words, short the rare 100-year event, go long the global finance markets, which have a 70% liklihood of increasing year on year. This is good risk taking.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)